I have been sick as a dog for the last few days and my hopes to go out and shoot some video with the 70D this weekend pretty much is a bust. I decided to mess around at home and try a few things out. An easy test would be to try and match the Canon EOS C100 and Canon EOS 70D cameras. Well it’s not exactly easy but it doesn’t require me running around shooting.
Here is the setup or lack of one. Roamed the home for RGB sample. I did pretty good! I found a flat lit area in my backyard and set the Canon 70D and Canon C100 up with the same lens. The Canon 40mm f2.8.
I had to use a ND filter on the 70D to get proper exposure. Both cameras white balanced independently since I had to use ND on the 70D. The Tiffen variable ND is very good and doesn’t soften the image.
Here are my settings for both cameras:
Canon 70D Setup
- Technicolor Profile
- Sharpness: 0
- Contrast: -4
- Saturation: -2
- Color Tone: 0
ISO 320. Why 320? The C100 base ISO is 850 so I felt 320 would yield a clean image on the more compressed codec and knew that I was grading the 70D image. I read that with the Canon EOS 5D Mark III the ISO should be set in multiples of 160 for the cleanest image. With the new sensor I’m not sure this remains true but to be safe I went with it
- Wide DR
- ISO 850
Above you can see the two camera with no correction and the scoops in the corner. After I shot the objects and brought the footage into Premiere Pro CC to compare.
I decided to grade the 70D footage instead of the C100. Here is why. If I’m going to use the 70D it won’t be a main camera so I would rather grade it to match the main camera. In this case it would be the C100.
Not bad. I got it pretty close and didn’t have to do that much work to it. The scoops don’t match but hey these are two very different cameras shot on two different codecs. I think this would work great.
In Premiere Pro I used Colorista II and added some unsharp mask to the 70D clip. The C100 is so much sharper than the 70D even with 50% unsharp mask added. The profile on the 70D has the sharpness down to 0, so this is definitely making the image softer. I might have to play around with this a little because it seems a little too soft to me. This is supposed to help with lowering noise in the image, but this is based on the 5D MKII and MKII cameras. If you have any insight on this please share.
As you can see I had to adjust the Shadow color and levels as well as the Midtones. I also took the saturation down even more to -15. That’s it! Very basic and didn’t take long to do at all. Not perfect but very usable.
In this grade I was focusing on the clay pot acting like it was skin tone and trying to match it. Since we look at people first skin tone matching is the most important. I see the green and red sift a little but the clay color is pretty close. Again I didn’t spend a ton of time grading the 70D footage. Knowing this makes it a little easier to trust using the Canon 70D as a B camera without being too worried about matching them up, With a little more grading I’m sure it could be even better.
While testing these two cameras I really noticed how much sharper and detailed the image the C100 is. The 4K CMOS sensor really makes a big difference. I had to add unsharp mask to around 200 to get the 70D footage to look closer but detail is something you can’t fix. It just has to be there.
Note: Article reposted from Eric's blog with permission
(cover photo credit: snap from Eric Naso)
Latest posts by erik naso (see all)
- Things That Drive Me Crazy About The Sony A7s - August 4, 2014
- Panasonic GH4 Performance Test at 96fps – how does it hold up? - May 4, 2014
- Firsthand Look at the Panasonic GH4 - April 28, 2014